There is an argument that is advanced in order to prove that either there is no god at all or that the god of the western religions can not exist. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Maimonides offered proofs for the existence of god, but he did not begin with defining god first, like many others do. The first argument for the existence of the monotheist god is the ontological one, by saint anselm. Buy the existence of god thirteenth edition by edited by john hick isbn. Arguments for the existence of god philosophy of religion. Religious studies, philosophy a2, religious language. John hick presents two philosophies which christians have used to explain the existence of evil in a universe created by a good god.
John hick was an internationally read and discussed philosopher of religion and theologian. While others may not have the ability to prove the existence of god, through anothers experiences, they also cannot disprove this existence. The author, a geological engineer, describes the geological systems of the earth, dating methods, including radiometric dating, and shows that the earth was made within thousands, not millions, of years. In this book we are concerned with philosophical arguments for the. The existence of god by john harwood hick goodreads.
Hick believes in evil being necessary in this world and that god exists with. It looks at the question of whether god exists, and whether or not we can prove that god exists. Buy arguments for the existence of god philosophy of religion series 1970 by hick, john, hick isbn. How does john hick explain the presence of evil in a world created by a benevolent god. The ontological argument has been argued from a group of philosophers for the existence of god.
In the selection hick explains a theodicy, a justification of gods goodness because of evil, the soulmaking view of life in this defense of gods way in the face of evil. Hick calls on plato, anselm, aquinas, hume, feuerbach, flew, and even himself, among others, to debate whether or not god is. If god does not exist is not a contradiction, then the ontological argument fails to prove god exists is an analytic truth. If god exists in the understanding alone, then a greater being can be thought.
John hick discusses in his essay the problem of evil, the objections to the belief in the existence of god is the presence of evil in the world. His argument was short, concise and impactful but continued to be logical and sensible. What are some criticisms directed to john hicks book. In my humble opinion, any one of the books below have sufficient scientific evidence to prove the existence of god. But as wellwritten and elucidated it is, there remains several points of clarification and considerations. Against this, hick offers his transcendent theism as a genuine spiritual alternative to meet the challenge of mechanistic materialism. The existence of god problems of philosophy series by. Perhaps what john hick is most known for is his pluralistic hypothesis. In direct contrast to william rowe is the soulmaking theodicy put forward by john hicks, a 20 th century philosopher. Start studying religious studies, philosophy a2, religious language. John hick, for example, studied the implications of religion as a whole. Sep 26, 2009 in sum, the existence of god edited by john hick is a good selection of classic excerpts for and against gods existence. Looking back, that experience proved to be a definitive turning point in my life. He presents five arguments for the existence of god and then presents the common challenges against those arguments.
I was surprised to find that there was scientific evidence for the existence of god. Gods existence cannot be proven in the way that science can prove or disprove a fact about the material world hebrews 11. The conception of god outlined in the preceding chapter is the outcome of many centuries of development during which some of the most acute minds of the. Hick supports the view of religious pluralismthe view that all religions have insight and truth into what is real, and no one religion is exclusively absolute. Without strong evidence, the proponent of the evidential problem of evil can stick to their claim that the amount and distribution of natural evil is strong evidence that god doesnt exist. The point of pascals wager is to prove that god exists. He argues that moral evil is a necessary result of finite persons moral agents acting freely. Pascal believes that belief in god is a rational act. Hick argues that moral evil is a result of the mystery of free will. Trying to prove that god exists is a difficult argument and many people have tried many different ways.
The existence of god in greek philosophy and muslim theology. John hick there is no use trying, said alice, one cannot believe impossible things. Belief on the basis of the spirits witness the good book blog. Lets see how the 23 authors in this book fare when dealing with this topic. Dec, 2015 there can be no doubt that john hicks an interpretation of religion has already made a huge impact in the field of philosophy of religion. Study 94 philosophy chapter 4 flashcards from lindsay m. As travelers along lifes way, its our goal to make sense of things, to try to understand the way the world is. The existence of god problems of philosophy series by john. Dec 05, 2019 how to argue that god exists christianity. Essay on does teh problem of evil disprove gods existence. As an agnostic brought up catholic, i found this to be a fascinating course. Philosophy chapter 4 philosophy 110 with merrill at. After that first book, i found other books with more scientific evidence. This is the basic insight on which thomas aquinas declared that god s existence was identical with the divine essence.
What is the evidence foragainst the existence of god. He begins by posing the traditional challenge to theism in the form of the dilemma. Thus god exists in the understanding, even if not in reality. God has revealed himself in science and also in history. Braithwaite concedes this argument, but explains that religious statements have ethical significance, while john hick asserts that the claim of gods existence is of a factual nature. In this book, john hicks examines how the belief of god has manifested throughout the ages. Ontological the energy of the mind is the essence of life. Philosophy of religion is the attempt to use reason as well as all the other resources available to us to understand the nature of religion. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Reviews of books with scientific evidence that god exists. We use book evil and the hiddenness of god put together by michael rea, which is a compilation of different essays taking the both sides.
The answer to that question helps define what one means when one discusses god if in fact there is any cognitive meaning at all. In this paper i will argue that in dialogue on good, evil, and the existence of god by john perry, the dialogue does not disprove the idea of god. Initially his belief in a loving god led him to inclusivism on the basis that such a god would not condemn nonchristians to hell. John hick s reason for his argument on the existence of evil is more convincing and logically true than b. Hick wrote many books during the course of his career and these reflect the gradual development of his pluralism. The principal philosophical arguments on the existence of god are brought together here. John hick s classic evil and the god of love, first published in 1968, set the contours for all subsequent discussion of the problem.
John hick and process theology on faith, freedom and theodicy. This argues that since everything in the universe needs a cause, to test this try playing the why game and asking why. The principal philosophical arguments on the existence of god a. Although somewhat dated, this book is useful reading for the student wishing to get a brief survey of some of the most influential thinkers for and against theism. Proponents of natural theology consider faith to be an appropriate source of evidence in the attempt to prove the existence of god. His many books have, between them, been translated into seventeen languages. This 1964 contains an excellent introduction by john hick as well as introductions to each of the presented writings in chapters of. For unbelievers, there are only a few ways to prove that god exists, depending on how willing they are to accept god s existence. Have you ever asked yourself where the universe came from. Essay cosmological argument on the existence of god. The existence of god in greek philosophy and muslim.
His theodicy does not necessitate a compromise of the three omniattributes but invokes the idea of a god that is as loving as he is patient. We are spiritual beings, created in gods image, aware of our own existence, and capable of choice. A major revolution in thinking about religion is called for in this challenging work by theologian and religious philosopher john hick. This book is an appraisal of hicks work on the specific topic of theodicy his. The author persuasively argues for a true religious pluralism, respectful of the nonchristian traditions that have persisted over timehinduism, buddhism, judaism, and islam.
In his theodicy, hick not only claims that there is no such thing as pointless suffering in the world, but that despite there being evil in the world, god still exists and he is still kind and omnipotent since the. Buy a cheap copy of the existence of god book by john harwood hick. As a pagan, i have to admit that there are quite a few scholars in the field of divinity, including the editor of this book, john hick. John hicks spiritual and theological journey to religious pluralism. John hick, introduction, in the existence of god, ed. Jan 01, 2020 god is a purposeful, personal, omnipotent, omnipresent, and an omniscient being. For unbelievers who are willing to believe in god, they often only need to be told about god and jesus christ in order to believe. In the existence of god, john hick introduces and presents theistic and nontheistic, ancient and modern arguments for the existence of god. Thomas aquinas vertical cosmological arguments for the existence of god.
Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. God is responsible for evil, using it as a soulbuilder to make human beings into morally perfect creatures. The main philosophers who will discuss why evil exist and if god himself exists as well are john hick and b. From the ancient greeks and anselm to the presentday and bertrand russell, both sides are represented. While you dont owe anyone an explanation for your faith, knowing how to defend. Belief on the basis of the spirits witness the good. More recently, it has been treated as a good inductive argument against the existence of god. Other of his significant works include arguments for the existence of god, god has. This experience would prove not only lifealtering but also important for his. The problem of evil is the oldest and most complicated theological problem in all of religious studies. First published in 1966, offers the main presentation of hicks soulmaking theodicy. John hick is known for his modern day version of the ontological argument.
In this book, john hicks examines how the belief of god has manifested. From the ancient greeks and anselm to the present day and bertrand. Does god hide from us john hick and process theology. Surely it is very unlikely that a god with the traditional attributes would have created a universe like this. In sum, the existence of god edited by john hick is a good selection of classic excerpts for and against god s existence. He believes the occurrence of nonmoral evil in the world is a necessary condition for the ethics of choice and the process of soulmaking. More than twenty books have been published about his work in english, german, french, chinese and japanese. But to exist in reality is greater than to only exist in the understanding. The eternal god is transcendent, not part of creation. Science and technology, general existence of god research greek mythology islam malaysia philosophy philosophy and religion philosophy of religion.
Reviews of books with scientific evidence that god exists x. For a list of his books see the referenced footnote. John hick argues that god made the world a paradise in which we could experience nothing but pleasure, thus human moral wickedness is the. The most influential contemporary solution to this problem has been offered by philosopher john hick. The hypothesis that god exists makes sense out of a wide range of the facts of experience. Anselms claim that the fool says in his heart there is no god, comes from which book of the bible. Complete summary of john hick s evil and the god of love. In hick s view, because god is good and loving, the environment that he has created for human life is naturally as pleasant and comfortable as possible.
Softback, exlibrary, with usual stamps and markings,in fair all round condition suitable as a study copy. John hick s important work on the problem of evil from the 1960s was a turning point in the study of theodicy. This was the way that people in the bible knew god. Arguments for the existence of god a crossroad book issue 1. Although somewhat dated, this book is useful reading for the student wishing to get a brief survey of some of. John hicks the problem of evil 2559 words bartleby. The existence of god based on religious experience essay. What compelling evidence do you yourself have that what you experience as. First come the contributions of western philosophers to the five arguments traditionally used to prove that god exists.
Moses ben maimon, widely known as maimonides, was a jewish scholar who tried to logically prove the existence of god. The prompt asked us to use the works of multiple theorists to try and prove the existence of god. After over 40 years of not believing that god exists, i was dared by a christian friend to read a book. John hick argues that god made the world a paradise in which we could experience. John hick contributes the basic arguments and reasons to deny, which basically have not changed in a thousand years. The argument merely indicates the probability of god and this is of little value to a religious believer. Several biographical points should be briefly mentioned. Philosophers, theologians, and apologists will benefit from reading this book. More about the existence of god based on religious experience essay. There can be no doubt that john hick s an interpretation of religion has already made a huge impact in the field of philosophy of religion. Now this isnt really an argument for god s existence. God is the infinite personal being who has created the universe, whom religious people worship and to whom they pray, and who has the power, when he or she so decides, to intervene in human affairs in response to our. For the fact that your holy book describes the inner witness of the holy spirit is. The existence of god john hick the principal philosophical arguments on the existence of god are brought together here.
Descartes used a version of the ontological argument to prove the existence of god. Dialogue on good, evil, and the existence of god by john. Debates over the existence of god can be tricky, especially since the burden of proof often falls on the believer. His argument was first presented in the form of a prayer in his book, proslogion, directed at the fool. And by divinity, i mean study of the monotheistic god. Arguments for the existence of god john hick download.
Rather, he used the description of the earth and the universe to prove the existence of god. Dec 14, 2009 i am writing on john hicks piece entitled there is a reason why god allows evil. Based on his dissertation, this first book of hicks presents his experiential account of christian faith. In the concluding chapters of evil and the god of love, hick will present the christian response to the problem of evil in eschatological terms, affirming a present interim dualism within the ultimate setting of an unqualifiedly monotheistic faith. The ontological argument thus attempts to prove the existence of god a priori by focusing on the nature of his existence or being.
Many have thought that the reality of evil in the world makes the existence of god unlikely and religious belief irrational. In this reading hick offers two responses to the problem of evil, one aimed at moral evil and the other at nonmoral or natural evil. The existence of god is part of collier books problems of philosophy series. As professor john hick explains, to them, god was not. Gods existence can be proven a priori, sample of essays. Examine the strengths and weaknesses of the argument for the existence of god based on religious experience. It may be, but it does show that physicists minds can conceive it. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. God is conceived as a being than which none greater can be thought, and even the nonbeliever can grasp that idea. Rather it is the claim that you can know that god exists wholly apart from arguments simply by immediately experiencing him. Although first published in 1964, this small 300page book contains many of the principal arguments on the existence of god from some very notable thinkers. Descartes and liebniz restate and expand on anselms argument. Original article, report by advances in natural and applied sciences. This pluralistic hypothesis is mainly a philosophical examination of religious pluralism.
805 930 1097 426 299 835 313 316 983 970 108 1594 205 1445 642 1412 976 364 1511 880 26 1053 815 74 218 598 375